Great Gatsby, The (2013)


Release date: May 10, 2013
Director: Baz Luhrmann
Novel by: F. Scott Fitzgerald
Screenplay by: Baz Luhrmann & Craig Pearce
Cast: Leonardo DiCaprio, Tobey Maguire, Carey Mulligan, Joel Edgerton, Elizabeth Debicki, Isla Fisher, Jason Clarke

Where many will complain about Fitzgerald’s novel being misplaced in Baz Luhrmann’s hands, The Great Gatsby has some undeniable charm that actually makes it a rather enjoyable watch for all its faults.

Long Island, 1922: Nick Carraway (Maguire) arrives at his new shack in West Egg and soon meets a mysterious millionaire, Jay Gatsby (DiCaprio), known for throwing lavish parties at his mansion. He befriends Gatsby and soon discovers that the man was once and is still in love with Nick’s cousin Daisy (Mulligan), who is now married to Tom Buchanan (Edgerton) and lives across the water in East Egg. It is when Gatsby and Daisy attempt to rekindle an old romance that conflict arises and everyone in their midst is pulled into disaster.

Considering this is Baz Luhrmann, no one should be surprised that he goes all out with the Jazz Age. Not quite so over the top as Strictly Ballroom and Moulin Rouge, but it certainly does go far. The camera is always restless, hustling and bustling to get as much of this story in as possible, the dialogue is often humorous in the first act, and the sets are as beautiful and extravagant as you might expect all throughout. Even the 3D, which is fairly useless most of the time, adds a special little touch and depth to certain details that makes it all the more aesthetically pleasing.

If you’re anything like me, you never wanted to see people from the twenties dancing to or Jay-Z and you’ll want to forget it soon after. For all the obnoxious modern music he splices into his film, he actually does utilize a few jazz pieces very well. The most impressive of the bunch is during Leonardo DiCaprio’s introduction as Gatsby as he waltzes in offering Carraway a drink and the scene erupts in Gershwin’s Rhapsody in Blue with a close-up on DiCaprio’s face and fireworks going off all around.

DiCaprio is the shining star of the film and Luhrmann knows it. He’s got the charm and talent to make a perfect Gatsby, and listening to him say “old sport” constantly is a delight. He also hits Gatsby’s darker moments perfectly and descends nicely into madness just as he has done in multiple roles. Much like Moulin Rouge, Luhrmann and Craig Pearce take the same route in grounding Gatsby in a man, Carraway in this case, writing a novel and telling his story through flashbacks. This doesn’t necessarily mean that Tobey Maguire is all that great of an actor, and while he does fine a good portion of the time, he desperately needs to learn when not to overact and avoid yelling.

Thankfully, Baz Luhrmann is far from preoccupied with Nick Carraway, as he prefers to fall into Daisy and Jay’s relationship as much as possible, sometimes ignoring the minor characters a little more than he should. However shallow a human being she might be playing, Carey Mulligan gives Daisy some depth, which makes the chemistry between her and Leo all the better. At times it seems like all subtlety is lost on Luhrmann, emphasizing some of the book’s aspects in the wrong way and almost like all he cares about is romanticizing their love affair a little more than he should be.

This attention to the relationship between Gatsby and Daisy does, however, result in some of the best scenes. Nothing is quite as good as the confrontation, in which every secret is thrown out into the open between Jay, Daisy, Tom, Nick, and Jordan, the last of whom is played by Debicki, who is shamefully underused in the film. It is at that point where Edgerton gets the chance to shine alongside DiCaprio, and the film is at its prime before a slow denouement.

Every party has its highs and lows, and The Great Gatsby is no different. It has its fair share of missed opportunities and flaws, but considering no one will ever make a perfect adaptation of The Great Gatsby, Baz Luhrmann’s often fun yet melancholic film is good enough.

Rating: ★★★½☆ 

Juan Barquin

Just yer average twenty-something college student with no time on his hands who ends up watching (and writing) too many movies and shows for his own good.

10 Responses

  1. Camiele says:

    Another brilliant review, love. I think DiCaprio is the Depp to Luhrmann’s Burton, if that makes any sense. I mean, they don’t work together very often (the last time was Romeo + Juliet, yes?), but when they do something magical seems to happen. I’ll always love Baz, all his self-indulgences and over-the-topness notwithstanding. Though I may be the only person on the planet that wasn’t totally into Moulin Rouge, I’ll always see anything Baz Luhrmann makes.

    So what’s the verdict? Was this adaptation better overall than Jack Clayton’s script and Robert Redford’s turn as Gatsby?

    • Rodrigo says:

      @Camiele, Comparing DiCaprio to Depp in that way offends me, haha. While Depp is wildly hit and miss, DiCaprio isn’t like that (he didn’t do much for me in J. Edgar, but otherwise he’s good-to-great) and was easily the best part of Gatsby (first time I ever saw any adaptation of TGG) and I did enjoyed the film — I might as well get labeled as a Luhrmann fan since I also liked Australia despite its false endings (?).

      I think the problem with translating Gatsby to film (or tv, if there’s any adaptation of TGG for it) is Carraway. He’s not that interesting of a character and Luhrmann constantly had Carraway out there for a good chunk of the film despite the other characters in Carraway’s life being far more interesting to watch. Maguire isn’t to blame for all of this, but while playing Gatsby sounds deliciously fun, Carraway just seems like a side-pet.

      Still good to watch because of the characters and Lurhmann’s visuals, though. Maybe my opinion will lower later on, but I did saw Gatsby with a discount ticket, lol.

      • Camiele says:

        @Rodrigo, I wasn’t comparing DiCaprio to Depp in terms of acting or films chosen. I’m talking just about the relationship between director and actor. What Depp is to Burton, DiCaprio seems to be to Luhrmann, in that they make incredible films together, that’s all. For the record, I will always adore anything DiCaprio does and I have just as much love and respect for Depp, so even if I were to compare the two in terms of acting–which I’d never do in the first place because their styles are vastly dissimilar–I would never do so in a way that’s to suggest one isn’t as good as the other.

        • Rodrigo says:

          @Camiele, Still tough to asociate DiCaprio with Luhrmann in that way since they just barely did 2 films together while Depp and Burton did like 8 together.

  2. Camiele says:

    @Rodrigo, Again… missing the point… HaHA.

  1. November 4, 2013

    […] them made it to the list and only 3 of them didn’t get a single vote at all (to be fair with The Great Gatsby, the film’s release date got bumped to this year, a move none of us had in mind during the […]

  2. November 7, 2013

    […] The Great Gatsby […]

  3. February 4, 2014

    […] how DiCaprio looks amazing and very charming — not surprising, considering he fared great in The Great Gatsby as a similar character minus the aggresive lifestyle — at playing the guy whose over-the-top […]

  4. June 14, 2014

    […] music video, resembling bits and pieces of Stanley Kubrick’s Eyes Wide Shut and The Great Gatsby, was directed by Dawn Shadforth who directed music videos for Kylie Minogue and Goldfrapp, and had […]

  5. September 20, 2014

    […] Unchained premieres on Christmas Day against Baz Luhrmann’s The Great Gatsby, which also stars Leonardo […]

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.