Elite Squad (2007)

Original Title: Tropa de Elite
Release date: August 17, 2007
Director: José Padilha
Book by: André Batista, Rodrigo Pimentel, Luiz Eduardo Soares
Screenplay by: John Kaylin, Bráulio Mantovani, José Padilha
Cast: Wagner Moura, André Ramiro, Caio Junqueria, Milhem Cortaz, Fernanda Machado, Fábio Lago, Maria Ribeiro, Paulo Vilela

I’m in an unusual spot, having seen Tropa de Elite 2 prior to this one. How do both films compare to each other when watched backwards? They’re mad entertaining with a tinge of social studies. I love it.

In Tropa de Elite, we’re introduced to Captain Nascimiento (Moura) who’s about to leave his days at the Special Police Operation Battalion (BOPE, from its Portuguese name), but before he goes back to his wife and newborn, he must find his replacement — and he’s choosing between rookies Matias (Ramiro) and Neto (Junqueria).

Of course, life isn’t always simple, and the BOPE gets their new assignment to do a criminal and drug dealer clean-up before the Pope arrives, because no politician wants a dead Pope in their city. A lot of killing goes on and a lot of eyebrows are raised.

Tropa de Elite is unapologetic and it’s not afraid to offend anyone — you can just see it in the scene where they are told about the Pope mission and Nascimiento’s voice-over ponders whether or not the Pope realizes that in order to sleep well at night at his chosen favela, so many have to die. And believe me, Pope John Paul II was an awesome Pope. However, the situation painted right there and then is something that we — developing countries’ population — ask ourselves over and over again whenever there’s an important world meeting in our cities. If you are not ready to take it as it is, you probably shouldn’t be holding your meeting here at all.

The film also takes its time to introduce us to BOPE and its incredibly grueling selection process that would intimidate any regular person, like you or me. However deceiving the title of the film may be, Tropa de Elite doesn’t really feel like a mindless action flick about the special service, but a social study of Brazilian society — and maybe overall Latin America and then some — in which we observe the relationship between regular people, people in power, and the people who chose to serve society and protect it.

Tropa de Elite is a film on hypocrisy — the hypocrisy human beings have for other human beings… pointing our fingers at one another for doing something that we on the side, very well knowing, do. All masked under the impression that it’s a butt-kicking action movie. It’s perfect.

Of course, this was labeled a propaganda film [1] by most English-based professional media, even though it was a huge success in Brazil — where some even dubbed it better than City of God. The truth is, they can’t really be compared, but people looking for the artistry displayed in City of God will probably be left a bit disappointed. However, there hasn’t been a recent take on contemporary society that doesn’t rely on metaphoric imagery *cough District 9 cough* in recent memory. Tropa de Elite and Tropa de Elite 2 have done so in an accessible way for regular movie-watching audiences.

Rating: ★★★★☆ 


YAM Magazine editor, photographer, blogger, translator and part-time web designer. Film junkie, music junkie… and lately series (a.k.a. TV) junkie.

8 Responses

  1. Mirella says:

    Man, my brother loves this movie (and the sequel and City of God) and recomends it to everyone XD

    • amy says:

      @Mirella, it’s really REALLY good because it’s really accessible because we’ve all lived through it, so it’s super easy to connect with the characters.

  2. I saw this movie recently and yeah, people are looking too much at the surface to call it a simple propaganda film. Also, how annoying were those college classmates? I’ve known people like them…

    • amy says:

      @Diandra Rodriguez, it’s interesting to compare this one with Tropa de Elite 2, though. Seeing people labeling this one as Right propaganda, and the other one as Left (or socialist) propaganda xD They’re great at complimenting each other :)

      And I know a lotttttt of people like those college students. It’s interesting to see when elections are coming up.

  1. September 19, 2013

    […] Me sorprendí cuando Sector 9 se convirtió en una de mis cintas favoritas del 2009 [1] ya que nunca hubiera considerado el género de la ciencia ficción como algo importante. Esa es una de las razones por las cuales le estaba prestando atención a Elysium, quería quedar igual de anonadada. Es culpa mía al emocionarme sin razón al ver a Jodie Foster, y exaltarme al ver múltiples veces a Wagner Moura en Tropa de Élite [1][2]. […]

  2. October 6, 2014

    […] para ella. Si tuviera que compararla con alguna cinta, el título más cercano sería la brasileña Tropa de Elite (no su secuela), una película de corte social (o sociológico) haciéndose pasar por […]

  3. October 13, 2014

    […] I was very surprised that District 9 became one of my favorite films of 2009 [1] because before it, I wouldn’t have given much consideration to sci-fi as a genre. This is one of the main reason why I had set my eyes on Elysium, I wanted it to blow me away. It’s partly my own fault because I was all giddy to see Jodie Foster, and was all pumped after watching and re-watching Wagner Moura on Elite Squad [1][2]. […]

  4. November 25, 2015

    […] I had to compare it with any movie, the closest title that comes to mind has to be Brazil’s Elite Squad (not its sequel), a social (or sociological) film posing as an entertainer, though Brazil edges […]

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.